Fluttershy opened her eyes slightly. It was still night out. She groaned and got herself out of bed. She figured she could have a midnight snack. Maybe some cupcakes Pinkie Pie baked me earlier, she thought to herself.

She got the cupcakes from her fridge and closed the fridge door. She set the plate on her table and removed the sryan wrap. Soon, she was munching on cold cupcakes. She knew she wasn't supposed to eat these delightful baking items, but she could cared less. She was tired and was hungry.

Suddenly, Fluttershy heard a small rapping on her door. She gasped quietly. Who could be at her door in the middle of the night? She walked to her door and grasped the door knob, then stopped. What if it was someone who wanted to harm her? She didn't know anybody who would be at this hour, so it could be anybody.

Reluctantly, Fluttershy slowly opened the door, to reveal Rainbow Dash wearing a brown robe. She looked grim, as if bad news was recently given to her. Fluttershy was surprised by this. Why is she here?

"Rainbow Dash? It's late. Why are you here at such an hour?" Fluttershy questioned.

"Fluttershy... I have bad news," Rainbow Dash said, with a sad expression on her face. Fluttershy waited to hear the news, hoping nobody was hurt.

"Fluttershy... Pinkie Pie died," Rainbow Dash said, trying to hold back tears. Fluttershy gasped. She was completely surprised by this news. How did she die? She wanted answers.

"How did she die? She was healthy just yesterday," Fluttershy asked, curious as how she died. But she also had a feeling that she didn't want to know.

"She was murdered. In her bedroom. Blood was everywhere. Nobody knows who did it. It's horrible."

At this point, Fluttershy was in utter shock. She didn't know what to think about this. Thoughts raced through her mind, looking for answers she can't find. She stared at Rainbow Dash, looking at her tear-stricken eyes. Fluttershy, however, didn't say a word for a few moments.

"Rainbow Dash..." Fluttershy started to ask. Rainbow Dash looked up to Fluttershy, wondering what she would say next.

"I want to know who did it."

Fluttershy arrived at the scene just a mere two minutes later. Everypony was there, including Fluttershy's friends. Many were talking to each other, some even crying. The mayor of the town was also there, wondering the same thing everyone else was: Who killed Pinkie Pie?

Fluttershy started to walk up the house, but two Equestrian guards blocked her path.

"Sorry, miss. Only people who qualify are allowed in," the right guard said.

"I'm sorry, but I am Pinkie Pie's best friend. I would like to know who did this," Fluttershy replied, anxious to see what is inside. The left guard shook his head.

"I'm sorry, miss. But I'm afraid that this area is only open to detectives. We may ask you to come for questioning later..." the left said. Fluttershy dropped her head.

"Alright, then. I guess I'll come later," she said, giving the guards sad eyes. The two guards exchanged glances, then turned to the sad Fluttershy.

"Farewell. But I must warn you. The scene might be... gruesome... for you. Are you sure you want to do this?" the right guard asked.

Fluttershy widened her eyes. She nodded her head. The two escorted Fluttershy into the house. The right guard opened the door knob, and the three entered.

The air smelled of rotten eggs and was hot and humid. The entire room was littered with blood, with blood on the walls, floor, objects and furniture. Fluttershy had to hold back vomiting from the amount of blood in the room, added with the stench.

Fluttershy looked in wonder at the amount of blood. It looks like the murderer killed Pinkie Pie messily, Fluttershy thought. Every step she took, she stepped in a puddle of red blood and intestines. She would even find some traces of Pinkie Pie's tail.

She soon noticed a trail of blood leading to her fridge. She followed the blood trail. She stood in front of the fridge. She grasped the bar. Shaking, she opened the door slowly. The contents of the fridge was the most horrifying sight she has ever seen.

It was Pinkie Pie's head, smiling right at Fluttershy with her teeth and eyes still intact. Fluttershy screamed, and slipped in a puddle of blood. Fluttershy's body was painted with patches of blood. She started to cry, wishing she never entered this god forsaken house.

Fluttershy stood up, sniffeling. She noticed a sheet of paper stuck to her tail. She took the paper out of her tail and examined it. The lettering was messy and painted with blood. It looked like one of Pinkie Pie's party invitations, if it was on scrap paper and painted red. It read:

"To all my friends of Ponyville,"

"I never thought it would end this way, but things happen! I realized everyone at Ponyville, who avoided me for a few weeks because I was acting "weird", hated me. THEY HATE ME! I ALWAYS KNEW!!!"


"I decided that taking my own life would be better than suffering the effects of social issues. I would like to take the time to name all the people who hates me..."


"Now, it's time. It is time to kill myself, in hope that there is a good god that will take care of me, better than my so-called friends.


"Pinkie Pie"

"P.S: Sorry for the poison in those cupcakes, Fluttershy."

The last line shook Fluttershy. She was already crying at the entire note, but she was now completely frightened.

"P.S.: Sorry for the poison in those cupcakes, Fluttershy."

That line kept flashing in her mind as she kept re-reading it. She felt dizzy. Not from the cupcakes, but from this entire dilemma all together. A piercing pain started throbbing in her brain, as all the thoughts raced in her mind. Moments later, she blacked out.

Fluttershy soon woke up in a hospital bed. She was still dizzy, but better. A nurse was at her side, along with her friends. They all looked at her with great worry. They smiled weakly at her.

"Hey, Fluttershy," Twilight said.

"Ugh. How long was I out?" Fluttershy asked.

"For a few days. You were extremely lucky. If we didn't operate sooner, well..." The nurse said, then stopped. Rainbow Dash's were red with tears.

"Don't worry. It's all over now," Applejack said. She gave her a banquet of flowers. Fluttershy sniffed the flowers. They smelled beautiful.

"Thank you, all of you," Fluttershy said weakly.

"You should probably rest for now. You will be up and about in a few days," The nurse said. Fluttershy nodded, and everyone exited the room. Fluttershy closed her eyes, attempting to sleep. She knew why Pinkie Pie was mad. Everyone thought she was acting strange earlier, like giving people death threats, writing strange symbols on certain landmarks, and just saying odd sentences. She muttered to herself most of the time, and kept saying something about "The Eyeless Forest". Nobody knew anything about what she was saying. But it was probably better to keep everything unanswered.

Suddenly, Fluttershy heard a small tap. She opened her eyes slightly and stared at the window of her room. The head of Pinkie Pie was staring right at her, with the same smile from the fridge.

Fluttershy screamed.

Ad blocker interference detected!

Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.